SMCC Economy Run - Montreal - 6/9/12

Events that are not Sponsored or Organized by the SCCV.
Post Reply
User avatar
Mike Kamm
Posts: 191
Joined: Fri Jun 10, 2005 2:07 pm
Location: Albany, NY

SMCC Economy Run - Montreal - 6/9/12

Post by Mike Kamm »

Image

Click on the flyer for full event info.

Saturday, June 9th, 2012.

A fuel economy rally on fun to drive roads. The goal is to stay on time while minimising fuel consumption. There will be several elapsed time controls at which you may arrive early without penalty. Controls may only be located at the end of a section (EOS). Penalties will be accorded based on fuel consumption and lateness. There will equally be penalties for leaving a control before the given out-time. No previous experience is required to participate. 100% asphalt. Any car can complete the event without problems. The route is identical to the both the 2010 & 2011 events allowing comparisons with previous results.

Image

Image

Here are last June's results converted to mpg:

1977 Datsun B210 [1.4 liter] 60.40 mpg
2005 Smart [.8 liter diesel] 56.81 mpg
2010 Smart [1.0 liter gas] 58.94 mpg
2011 Honda Civic Hybrid 53.45 mpg
1999 Toyota Tercel 52.38 mpg
2001 Toyota Echo 51.80
2011 Hyundai Elantra 43.23 mpg
1992 Toyota Levin GT-Apex 41.85 mpg
1985 Toyota MR2 30.37 mpg
2007 Suzuki SX4 AWD 31.44 mpg

Distance : 198km

Classes : Gasoline, Diesel & Hybrid(e)

FIA affiliated rally club members : $30
Otherwise : $40
Last edited by Mike Kamm on Sun Jun 03, 2012 11:16 am, edited 1 time in total.
2013 Honda Fit EV
'97 Geo Metro
User avatar
Niburu
Posts: 70
Joined: Fri Feb 03, 2012 11:10 am
Location: Malta, NY

Re: SMCC Economy Run - Montreal - 6/9/12

Post by Niburu »


1977 Datsun B210 [1.4 liter] 60.40 mpg
so 35 years ago we could do this
shouldn't most economy cars be gettting WAY more than mid 30's mpg by now
2011 Forester - DD//1990 Miata - Beater//1983 porsche 911 Targa - Moneypit
User avatar
Mike Kamm
Posts: 191
Joined: Fri Jun 10, 2005 2:07 pm
Location: Albany, NY

Re: SMCC Economy Run - Montreal - 6/9/12

Post by Mike Kamm »

Niburu wrote: So 35 years ago we could do this.
Well, B210's got between 30 and 45 mpg back in the day, [really depends on who was driving it] but mine has been tweaked a little :wink: . My B210 weighs less than 2000 lbs., has no power steering, no power brakes, no a/c, no power anything! And you wouldn't want to get hit by a 7500 lb. SUV with it though.
Niburu wrote:Shouldn't most economy cars be gettting WAY more than mid 30's mpg by now?
Yes but today's cars are built too "safe" to make them pass today's crash standards. Also working against best mileage is that they have far too many heavy convenience items that simply cost fuel mileage. Another problem is lazy people with bad habits. How many times have you seen someone sitting in their car in a parking lot playing with thier smart phones while idling with the A/C on? That's the best way to get 0 mpg!

I'm thinking that 1.4 liters may be a bit too big for these competitions, so this year I will use my newly aquired 1.0 liter Geo Metro. :mrgreen:

Mike
2013 Honda Fit EV
'97 Geo Metro
User avatar
DaveP189
Posts: 700
Joined: Sun Aug 31, 2008 11:05 pm
Location: Massena via Malletts Bay

Re: SMCC Economy Run - Montreal - 6/9/12

Post by DaveP189 »

Mike Kamm wrote:Yes but today's cars are built too "safe"
Agree with that: rising "safety" requirements/equipment - stronger door beams, bazillion air bags, internal crash & rollover structures - plus...
Mike Kamm wrote:...far too many heavy convenience items that simply cost fuel mileage.
...heated seats, moonroof, power everything - equals a MINI Cooper thats an inch short of 12 feet, yet weighs 2553 stock :rock: - but I do get 34-35 in 'normal' highway driving.
(my '85 GLH Turbo was bigger and right around 2000)
Dave P. #189 '02 MINI CooperS+ "Elphie"
"People who dance are considered insane by those who can't hear the music." -unknown
User avatar
Mike Kamm
Posts: 191
Joined: Fri Jun 10, 2005 2:07 pm
Location: Albany, NY

Re: SMCC Economy Run - Montreal - 6/9/12

Post by Mike Kamm »

Just under a week before the event now. I have taken my [newly aquired specifically for this event] '97 Geo Metro from rust bucket to properly functioning automobile in the last month or so.

Image

I told myself not to buy any more cars that are rusted out, it's just not worth the time to fix them. And that was the plan...... until the phone rang. It was Dave B. letting me know of a car for sale by one of his customers. It was a rusty one for sure but with the 2012 Economy Run season coming up I could not resist the opportunity to own the Holy Grail of fuel economy, a 3 cylinder 5-speed Geo Metro. The price was right too, at exactly it's scrap value. The prior owner kindly left a note in the car listing all of the problems that needed attention. At the end of the note he said that they called the car "Fred".

Image
I brought Fred home and put him in the air to take a look. OMG, what was I thinking?

Image
I came very close to taking Fred to the scrap yard several times, but because it ran perfectly, had a full new exhaust system and brakes all around, I started sorting it out one problem at a time.

Image
The rust extended beyond the rocker panel and into the floor board as well. I had to lift up the carpet and wiring harnes inside to keep from melting them while welding.

Image
So I got to work with cutting out and shaping new rocker/floor patch panels.

Image
I didn't have a piece of sheet metal 36" long so I had to make it a two piece repair panel.

Image
Ready to grind down and smooth out for paint.

Image
Underside of floorboard.

Image
The fuel tank also leaked when it was filled up. At Economy run events we top up to check how much fuel we used, so neglecting this repair was not an option. Finding a replacement was not cheap or easy. Used ones were simply not available from yards around here.

Image
So I ordered and installed a new tank for $256 [which more than doubled my investment in this car.]

I also scrubbed out the filthy interior and blew the acorns out from under the hood. Then I installed a stereo cd player back into the hole in the dash where the original one used to be. As the radio harness wires had been cut, I had to go online and find a schematic to know what wires went where.

It is a well known weak area of any year Geo metro that the front frame horns rot out. This is the area where the tie rods come through and the front suspension mounts. This is what a good one should look like.

Image

...and here's what mine looked like before I peeled back the undercoating.

Image

...and after a bit more poking.....

Image

Image
This is a view from the back side of that same frame horn. Look how little metal was left supporting the lower control arm!

Image
Patterns were cut from card stock [cereal boxes] and transferred to new steel.

Image
After lots of grinding and no less than 6 hand cut pieces of steel were fitted and welded in.

Image
Just before smoothing and priming.

Today I'm sanding bondo and might possibly have time to buff out what's left of the white paint.
2013 Honda Fit EV
'97 Geo Metro
User avatar
Mike Kamm
Posts: 191
Joined: Fri Jun 10, 2005 2:07 pm
Location: Albany, NY

Re: SMCC Economy Run - Montreal - 6/9/12

Post by Mike Kamm »

Less than a week away.

Image

Vermont's Ken Snowman will be bringing his gas class "FrankenJetta" out this weekend to Montreal. He is leaving early on Friday to give himself plenty of extra time at the border crossing!

He's been working on optimizing the profile of his boat tail, and plans to have some paint on it before the weekend.

Image

Image

Event organizer Jeff Dungen added a chin spoiler to his 20 valve JDM Toyota Levin Apex GT.

Mike
2013 Honda Fit EV
'97 Geo Metro
User avatar
Mike Kamm
Posts: 191
Joined: Fri Jun 10, 2005 2:07 pm
Location: Albany, NY

Results for the 2012 SMCC Economy Run

Post by Mike Kamm »

Image

Raw results converted to mpg's:

Gas Class:

1. Darin Cosgrove, 2000 Insight: 76.12 mpg.
2. Mike Kamm, 1997 Geo Metro: 64.43 mpg.
3. William Morin, 1999 Toyota Tercel: 53.33 mpg.
4. Francis Reid, 2005 Toyota Echo: 50.80
5. Jeff Dungen, 1992 Toyota Levin GT Apex: 50.15 mpg.
6. Luc Lachambre, 2013 Smart ForTwo: 48.90 mpg.
7. Patrice Quenneville, 2008 Smart ForTwo: 46.03 mpg.
8. Ken Snowman, 1990 VW "FrankenJetta": 43.88 mpg.
9. Chris Werner, 1997 Saturn SW2 wagon [with four passengers]: 41.19 mpg.
10. Nathalie Wing, 2010 Smart ForTwo: 40.14 mpg.
11. Stephanie Beaulieu, 2009 Smart ForTwo: 39.93 mpg.

Diesel Class

1. Frederic Bedard, 2005 Smart ForTwo: 73.50 mpg.
2. Marc-Andre' Lajeunesse, 2006 Smart ForTwo: 62.22 mpg.
3. Michel Cuerrier, 2005 Smart ForTwo: 57.95 mpg.
4. Martin Boisvert, 2005 Smart ForTwo: 48.30 mpg.

Hybrid Class

1. Mathieu Laframboise, 2012 Toypta Prius C: 58.07 mpg.

For the third straight year we had perfect weather! Kudo's to Jeff and the SMCC for another great event up north. I couldn't have been more pleased with second overall in my stock '97 Geo Metro.

But the overall winner was...

Image
Darin Cosgrove of Ecomodder.com. He won overall this year with his 2000 Honda Insight. It is a very efficient car with it's lean burn engine, light curb weight, and superior aerodynamics. And Darin knows how to get every bit of efficiency out of it!

The nice thing about this event is that it uses the same route each time so you can compare your results from year to year. I've run in all three events and these are my raw mpg results to date:

2010 - 2.0L '93 Sentra SE-R: 57.74 mpg
2011 - 1.4L '77 Datsun B210: 60.40 mpg
2012 - 1.0 L '97 Geo Metro: 64.43 mpg.

There is more good news, participation for this event was up again this year. The number of vehicles competing:

2010 - 6 cars
2011 - 10 cars
2012 - 16 cars

Image
My Metro parked next to Ken Snowman's wild 1990 gas powered "FrankenJetta".

Image

Image
Check out Francis Reid's Toyota Echo. I love wild aero mods!

Image
They called this car the Duck Nose Echo.

Image
Underneath view. He had a full belly pan and side skirts like I had on my SE-R last year. This thing was cool!

Image
The turnout from Team Smart Quebec was very impressive with no less than 8 entries. Four were gas powered and the other four were with the .8 liter diesels. The best one was a diesel driven by Frederic Bedard, at a great 73.50 mpg.

Image
Organizer Jeff Dungen's rare RHD Toyota Levin Apex GT had it's best outing ever at 50.15 mpg. This is with a high performance 20 valve 1.6 liter engine with individual throttle bodies!
2013 Honda Fit EV
'97 Geo Metro
Post Reply